Emmie Mears
SFF. Queer AF.

Saor Alba: Why I Believe in Scotland’s Independence

    Home  /  Blog  /  Saor Alba: Why I Believe in Scotland’s Independence

Saor Alba: Why I Believe in Scotland’s Independence Image

Saor Alba: Why I Believe in Scotland’s Independence

Scotland, referendum 2014, Yes Scotland

I ought to start this with a disclaimer. I do not hold a British passport; I am not a subject of the Queen. I will have no legal right to vote on this subject in the autumn of 2014. But it matters to me.

I hope one day to make my home in Scotland. I would like to raise my children there. I want to bring my family back to to the land of my ancestors. There are Scots on every branch of my family tree. Some of them are closer to the trunk than others, but they’re all there. Since 2004, I’ve spent a lot of time in Scotland. The first time I ever went, I was alone. It was me, a large rucksack, and two months that changed my life.

The north-west point of mainland Scotland, John O’Groats.

I spent over eight weeks there that summer. Listening, learning, absorbing. I saw everything from misty glens to sheer faced cliffs. I climbed Ben Nevis and visited chambered cairns and standing stones. But what I recall most about that trip were the people.

From the Glasgow cabbie who cheerfully bid me “Welcome home!” when I told him I had Scottish ancestry to Robin, a young man from Rothesay, who took me out with his friend Neil to fly on the beaches of St. Andrews — they accepted me and welcomed me. Kind and gracious and welcoming are the Scots.

It’s on this beach I tried to fly. Parachute. Harness. Gust of wind. 20 feet in the air only to be dropped on my arse. I washed it off in the North Sea and found sand in various orifices for weeks to come. Weeks. Thanks, Robin and Neil.

That land snared me so tight that I found ways to go back year after year. At Christmas in 2006, a few New Zealanders introduced me to the Scottish band Albannach. Albannach means, quite simply, “Scottish” or “Scots” in Gaelic. Their music is reminiscent of a time when drums served to make you dance, to make you fight, to stir your soul. From the first strains of Donnie’s pipes, they caught me. I’ve been fortunate enough to meet them several times and to see them live more times than I can count now — they breathe a fiery passion for their homeland, and they believe that a Scot is a Scot, even unto a hundred generations.

Even then, I’d seen Braveheart. It’s a romanticized portrait of a violent former time, to be sure, but the facts as they are remain unmolested. William Wallace was a hero. He led the Scots to many victories and a few losses. Some of those victories, like that at Stirling Bridge, were brilliant displays of tactics and courage by the outnumbered Scots. And it remains that Wallace paid for Scotland’s freedom with his blood and a horrific, torturous death long before Robert the Bruce was able to rally his countrymen to victory on the field at Bannockburn.

The Wallace Monument at Stirling. The bridge is long gone, but you can see Wallace’s sword at the top of the tower.

Robert Bruce himself is a paragon of Scotland’s heroes — and a bit maligned by Braveheart’s writers. He saw Scotland freed, and she remained thus for four centuries.

It should be noted, in the interest of fairness, that Scotland’s greatest enemy has — at times — been her own rulers. Nobles wooed by prospects of English titles or land, lured by empty promises at the expense of those who had no voice.

While doing my research on my family, I found a line of Scots that people on Ancestry.com were quick to believe came from the Earl of Panmure. It was exciting to think that perhaps I came from some noble house — but the facts didn’t line up. Some were content to leave those gaps unfilled, but I’m not. That Scot, with all the other Scots on my tree, was most likely a peasant. A crofter or a farmer, and likely no one of note. Indeed most of my Scottish ancestors had no voice. They were subject to the whims of their rulers, and I’ve no doubt that the political machinations of the time are what forced my forebears from their homeland.

For the first time, the people of Scotland have a say in what becomes of her. They didn’t have much of a choice when James Stuart, sixth of his name, landed on the thrones of both Scotland and England. They didn’t get to vote on the Act of the Union in 1707, and many Scots dissented — and were forcibly put down.

Monument at the Culloden Battlefield, where hundreds of Scots died fighting to return a Stuart to the throne. The battle was nearly a massacre in proportions, and what followed was brutal retaliation against the Highlanders.

Three hundred years have passed since then.

This time round, there is a chance for Scotland’s independence to come without bloodshed. This time round, I doubt it will come to that. I can most sincerely and fervently say that I hope it will not. The basis of my belief in Scotland’s independence is one of principle. Scotland is a discrete nation with a distinct culture and history. Why should she not have self-determination?

It bears mentioning as well that Scottish history is not the national history taught in Scottish schools. Scottish children learn British history, which is by and large an Anglocentric pursuit. I think that if more Scots had grown up learning more in-depth about her long and fascinating story, there would likely be greater support for independence. As children progress past primary school and onto secondary, a bit more emphasis is placed on Scottish history and identity, but it’s not the same.

I remember how I felt when I found that certain parts of American history had been glossed over in my classes. History should be the property of the people. It affects us and the choices we make.

From a political perspective, a split of the United Kingdom would be difficult. Would Scotland retain membership in the European Union? What would happen to the North Sea oil reserves? What would change? Would they get to keep golf? (Okay, that last was a joke.)

Those who are against Scottish independence say that the United Kingdom is more prosperous as a whole and that membership therein does not compromise the individual identity of its member nations. But under the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (which the UK has signed), Scotland has a right to self-determination if she so chooses.

Scotland of course benefits as a part of one of the world’s major powers — but what if the status quo  in your country’s foreign policy grossly diverges from your wishes? Such was the case in the last major election in the UK, with the Conservatives (Tories) winning on a national scale (England, Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland) when in Scotland they garnered a tiny 15% of the vote. Yes, you read that right. 85% of Scotland did not vote for the current UK government, but they don’t have the option to get out of it. Scotland is significantly more liberal than England, and when your country has five million people to your neighbor’s whopping 59 million, your voice gets lost in a very large crowd.

It’s difficult to be objective in a case like this, but then I’m not trying to be. I’m merely trying to express an opinion and give a few reasons for it.

I believe that Scotland should be free. She should have the chance to go it alone and make what she can of this new era. Her people are capable, hardworking, generous, and kind. They have eked out a living on a hunk of largely barren rock for ten thousand years. They have fought back superior forces and given us people like David Hume, Alexander Graham Bell, Alexander Fleming, Andrew Carnegie, Robert Burns, Adam Smith, Kirkpatrick MacMillan (Like bikes? He invented them.), Craig Ferguson, Julie Fowlis, and many more.

Why do I care about all of this? I guess it comes down to who I am. I am a Scot. What makes a Scot? Is it blood? Yes. Is it ancestry? Yes. Is it birth? Yes.

But beyond all those things, I think what makes a Scot is a passion for the land, her people, and her heritage. It’s the beauty of her languages — the cadence of Scots and the fluidity of Gaelic. It’s her haunting stories, lively reels, whirling jigs and the piercing sound of the pipes. It’s a belief, in her history and her perseverance. It’s hope for her future. It’s fire and passion born of rock and rain.

Even if you don’t support the coming referendum, a Scot can be any of those things and all of them. I am one. MacLennan and MacLachlan, Maule and MacMillan, Brown and Hamilton, Taylor and Mears. By blood and bone and the stories passed down from my ancestors who never forgot where they came from — I am one. And this Scot happens to believe that Scotland is a living place, and she must and shall go free.

Saor Alba.

Rainbow over Loch Ness — one of my favorite moments ever.

The aforementioned Scottish band Albannach are offering a new album entitled The Independence EP for free on their website. If you click the image below, you’ll be taken to the page where you can download it.

Click the image to be taken to Albannach’s website, where you can download this EP for free.

They are a band of patriots, people who genuinely believe in Scotland’s ability to govern herself. One of their dear friends, writer and historian David Ross, passed from this world two years ago. His life was a testament to that belief and will not be forgotten by any of us who were lucky enough to have met him.

Like this post? Subscribe to get more in your inbox!

Author | Emmie Comments | 11 Date | May 26, 2012



I stand with all those who seek and cherish freedom. Scotland time can not come soon enough.

As for her history, I stumbled across this BBC doc on YouTube:

It is very long, and it is “British-centric” but with a twist and doe snot belittle Scottish independence.

May 26, 2012 | 9:43 am

    Emmie Mears

    Thanks for sharing that! I’ve been studying the Picts lately, and this is quite fascinating.

    May 26, 2012 | 12:22 pm


I come from long lines of subjugated peoples (including Scots). Change is hard. Fear of the unkown is strong. But I think the world will more successfully move forward when we recognize and value our differences and work together—respectful of those differences. A hard balance to maintain, but I think we’d all be stronger and more secure in the end.

May 26, 2012 | 3:49 pm


Hi! Here’s a few good links on Picts you perhaps had not seen.


In fact, just get all your news from there whilst you are at it! ;-P

May 27, 2012 | 4:40 am


Thanks for the download link. I love Albannach, thanks for introducing me to them years ago.

May 27, 2012 | 5:19 pm


I come from a long line of Scots on my dad’s side and Cornish (gaelics from the SW of England) on my mums side. I currently live in England. I’m of two minds about Scotland gaining it’s independence. There are many things to gain for Scotland if it becomes independent, but the unknown will worry people. Under the current government system, Englands pays a lot more for presricptions and education than the Scots – how will small things like this be considered? In the current economic climate, people will most likely be swayed on whether its more economical to stay in the UK than to leave. Not necessarily the best long-term idea, but money (or lack of it) rules at the moment! As for the bloody Tories, I’m yet to find many English who admit to voting for them. Fixed votes, or just shame at their actions?!

May 29, 2012 | 7:36 pm

    Emmie Mears

    Hahaha…about the Tories, I have no idea how they got elected. All I know is that their policies throw a baboon onto my pyramid of champagne glasses.

    I wish I could see into the future and know what will come of the referendum, but I guess we’ll all just have to find out.

    May 31, 2012 | 2:47 pm

Pedro Correia

I’m a Scot living in Portugal, a small branch of Rollo clan came here centuries ago. I was looking for new stuff for my website and I stummbled upon your blog. I agree totally wiith you. I had no idea until now, or rather I had the usual idea that Scotland couldn’t survive without England, but apparentely it’s right the opposite, thanks to Northern Sea oil: something like 500 billion pounds have been drained out from Scotland and dropped into London vaults over the years…………………………….
Disgusting, isn’t it?
Keep on waving the flag, I’m doing the same here in Portugal


August 9, 2012 | 5:23 am

    Emmie Mears

    Hi Pedro!

    Thank you so much for stopping by and leaving such a thoughtful comment. I appreciate hearing the voices of people affected by this upcoming referendum so much — and in fact your comment inspired today’s blog post.

    Scotland is indeed endowed with many natural and human resources, and I strongly believe in her ability to not only survive as an independent, autonomous nation, but to thrive as a major player on the world stage.

    North Sea oil is of course a part of that, but far beyond the limited amounts of oil that exist on the planet, Scotland is pioneering clean, sustainable energy and passing projected goals for renewable resources. It’s that I believe that makes Scotland so ready for independence: her ability to innovate and her commitment to progress for the betterment of her people and the planet.

    Thank you again for sharing your thoughts. 🙂

    August 9, 2012 | 2:28 pm

Johnnie Sloan

Hi Emmie,

I’m from Glasgow and thoroughly enjoyed reading that. Your comment, ‘The basis of my belief in Scotland’s independence is one of principle’ is one I wish that everyone else in Scotland could take on and believe in. The author James Kelman said that it’s not a vote for the economy, it’s a vote for self-respect and your words reminded me of this. People are too scared by fudged facts and figures that are thrown at them each day and it clouds the history which could be the real factor.

I remember being taught about William Wallace and Robert the Bruce at primary school. We even went to two sites in Irvine to take take stone rubbings of cairns that had details of William Wallace. Then came secondary school and that was that. I’ve no recollection of ever being taught about the real history of ‘the union’ and only discovered through research by my own curiosity. I’d imagine the majority of Scots don’t know how we are in this situation.

Hopefully you’ll get to live in an Independent Scotland one day with the rest of us.



November 24, 2012 | 9:23 am

    Emmie Mears

    Thank you so much for your kind comment. 🙂

    I’ve heard many of my Scottish friends relate the same tale as you — that come secondary school, there was little to no mention of Scottish history insofar as it differed from “British history.” For the average person, it’s hard to learn such things unless taught, and very few people go out of their way to fill in gaps they don’t realise exist. A friend of mine, David Ross, set out to do just that when he found out how lacking his education had been about his own country’s history. He wrote a nice little cavalcade of books on the subject of Scottish History and even walked barefoot on the path of William Wallace to commemorate the seven hundredth anniversary of Wallace’s execution. He was a wonderful man and unfortunately passed away two years ago far, far younger than he ought to have.

    November 27, 2012 | 2:34 pm

Comments are closed.

  • Love this? Buy Emmie a Coffee. Mmm, coffee.

  • Newsletter of Newsiness Gets You A Free Ebook

    Want to be kept in the loop?

    * indicates required
    Email Format
  • Support My World-Making!

    Love my work or just want to support me directly? Come to my Patreon! You'll get all sorts of goodies in return!

    Available in ebook. Trade paperback coming soon!
  • STORM IN A TEACUP (Book One of the Ayala Storme Series)

    Available in trade paperback and ebook.
  • Follow me on Twitter!

  • Show Your Like

  • Emmie on Goodreads

    What I'll Be Reading in 2014

    The Tombs of Atuan
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list
    Mistborn: The Final Empire
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list
    The Blade Itself
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list
    Girl With a Pearl Earring
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list
    Magic Bites
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list
    Gone Girl
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list
    Claim Me
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list
    Shaman's Crossing
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: currently-reading and 2014-reading-list
    The Selkie Spell
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list

  • Emmie on Pinterest


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers