Emmie Mears
SFF. Queer AF.

The Trio: Do These Goofy Guys Spotlight Misogyny in Geek Culture?

    Home  /  Blog  /  The Trio: Do These Goofy Guys Spotlight Misogyny in Geek Culture?

The Trio: Do These Goofy Guys Spotlight Misogyny in Geek Culture? Image

The Trio: Do These Goofy Guys Spotlight Misogyny in Geek Culture?

Trio1

It’s Monday, gentle viewers, and welcome to the Hellmouth for the next week of Buffyversary posts! As always, be warned that there be spoilers in these here waters.

When we’re talking the Big Bad of season six, there’s a lot of dissent on who meets the criteria for that. If you go by Grave, it’s Willow. But there’s a whole lot of episodes that come before the season six finale. If you ask Joss, he’ll say that life is the Big Bad. And I get that. That said, I’ve always felt that the bumbling, insidious-but-ignorant trio personifies Life in Buffy’s sixth season. They’re the curveball that gets in the way when you’re just about to get what you want. They’re the demon that bursts in and robs a bank when you’re trying to get a loan. They’re the doofus who accidentally turns you invisible.

Sure, they’re silly. We laugh at Jonathan turning himself into a goofy-looking demon and getting pummeled by drunk Buffy. We groan at the mummy hand loop.

But, like most of Joss’ characters in the show, they serve a purpose other than being obnoxious comic relief.

Trio2

 

We’re Your Archnemesisis…es.

The Trio is made up of those guys. You know the ones. The one whose brother always overshadowed him (okay, so aspiring to be remembered for the flying monkeys you summoned to attack the school play isn’t exactly laudable). The one who was picked on so much he turned suicidal and who always tries the wrong thing to get attention and be loved. The one who’s pissed off at his girlfriend for leaving him and thinks he’s a nice guy. These guys are all too familiar. They’re people we went to school with. Hell, maybe they mirror parts of us.

When they get going in their little plot to team up and take over Sunnydale, their goals are pretty simple. Power, money, and “chicks, chicks, chicks.”

And that’s your first clue.

They look at Buffy as their biggest threat. It’s an interesting note because Jonathan was the one who gave Buffy her Class Protector award at prom. He knows how he owes his life to her, but to fit in with his friends, he classifies her as a threat. Right there is an underlying message: strong women are threats, even if they’ve helped you in the past.

The underlying messages parade into the forefront a few episodes later.

Katrina

 

Let’s backtrack to where we first met Warren back in season five. He’d created a robot for a sex toy. Then he met and fell in love with Katrina, who inconveniently found out about his little bot-lovin’ when the robot tracked him down in Sunnydale. Like most women, she didn’t think that her boyfriend having sex with a robot was particularly kosher, and even less so after said robot tried to kill her. So, she dumps him. I would too. Most likely, so would you.

Back to season six. Warren has moved on from making robots and now has a way to make Katrina love him again. Brainwash her!

The Trio goes to a bar to pick out a woman they will make into their sex slave. Right there I get the jibblies, because listening to them go, “The redhead! The redhead!” “No, the bazoombas!” creeps me out every time. They’re looking at human beings and treating them like toys. And it gets worse.

Warren, of course, always had his eyes on Katrina. He brainwashes her using magic, then brings her back to their house. And all the boys clamor about who gets to do it with her first. Warren says he does, but the others can have her “when he’s done with her.”

Take a moment to think about that. This is beyond rape we’re talking about. Because Katrina left him (with absolute perfect reason), Warren has utterly dehumanized her. She’s now nothing more but a body to be used for his pleasure and given away when he’s finished. I don’t even have words for how disgusting that is.

The problem for Warren is, Katrina has a strong mind and fights off his compulsion. And you don’t want a woman thinking for herself, do you?

She comes barreling out of Warren’s room, kicking him through the door. She’s visibly jangled, upset, terrified and humiliated.

“It’s rape.” She tells them.

To which Andrew and Jonathan protest. They say they didn’t mean to.

If you were watching the news yesterday for the Steubenville verdict, those words should be a frightening parallel. Buffy the Vampire Slayer is fiction, but that scene is all too reminiscent of this high profile case where a girl had no control and was violated by young men while many stood by and watched. While the initial perpetrators are of course to blame and should be dealt with accordingly, the people who stood by and watched or participated by filming it — there is something just as deeply wrong with that.

Someone who says “I didn’t mean to rape you” has absolutely no understanding of what rape is, yet they clearly operate on an “I wanted this, I took it, and now you’re mad at me for some reason” mindset. There are layers of issues with statements like that. Layers.

Warren may have been the mastermind behind this plan of the Trio’s, but Andrew and Jonathan helped. They planned to participate. And they never put it together that the women they were going to make their “willing sex slaves” (note how they even added the word willing to this statement to absolve themselves of blame) were being violated.

Because in the eyes of people who view women as toys, “unable to consent” equates to “willing.” It’s this attitude which needs to be attacked and eradicated. 

Andrew and Jonathan do eventually grow a conscience, and we all know what happens to Warren. But what they don’t mention outright is how the attitudes of Jonathan and Andrew are still displayed in geek culture. A few weeks ago I posted about how Gears of War gamemaker Chris Perna thought it was unlikely they’d ever create a female protagonist for their game, his subtext being that men aren’t interested in seeing strong women kill monsters. (Tomb Raider’s doing great, by the way, and all sorts of gamers are loving it even though Lara Croft is a female.)

Last year Joe Peacock wrote an inflammatory piece about the illegitimacy of female cosplayers that got a Scalzi-sized internet dropped on his head. The point is that within geek culture, there are still sectors where women are blatantly unwelcome. Peacock wrote that female cosplayers are only trying to get male attention, and he wasn’t alone in that thinking. (He also showed an alarming prejudice against good-looking women, which I’ve seen elsewhere to create a “no true Scotsman” sort of logical fallacy about physical attractiveness precluding one’s ability to identify as a geek or a nerd.) Within and without geek culture, there’s still a pervasive attitude that women wear clothes or reveal skin because they want to attract the attention of men. To sum up this attitude, the autonomy of women is irrelevant, and their actions exist only insofar as they relate to men and are filtered through that male perspective.

Katrina became a bitch for dumping Warren even though she had every logical reason to do so. If a guy’s robotic sex toy showed up on my doorstep, I’d dump a guy even if it gave me a hug instead of trying to crush me. But because she took that step, he eventually took her life. Because she fought back when he tried to rape her, and because she tried to get away from him again and exercise her right to her own body and life. He killed her for it.

I think that the Trio personifies life as the Big Bad in a lot of ways, and perhaps more subtly, the still male-dominated world that we live in. I’m never so blatantly reminded of these attitudes as during a trial for a prominent rape case like the one from Steubenville. There might not be that many Warrens in the world, but there are still heaps of Andrews and Jonathans, and THAT is what the world needs to address.

 

Like this post? Subscribe to get more in your inbox!

Author | Emmie Comments | 9 Date | March 18, 2013

comments

Daniel Swensen

Great post, Emmie. Something that always stuck with me with the Katrina episode, is after they kill her, they show no empathy for her at all. It’s all about themselves, and how their lives are going to be ruined, and why did their victim have to inconvenience them by being victimized and then killed like that? And I’m seeing this same sentiment reflected in the news media re: the Steubenville case. “Oh, those poor boys.”

March 18, 2013 | 10:52 am

    Emmie Mears

    Yeah, that is worth a post in itself. It can also be tied in with some recent events on The Walking Dead — a woman gets assaulted and her boyfriend makes it all about him and how it affects HIM. Even when people are trying to think of the victim, they think of it in terms of how it affects the men in her life. Her husband, her father — and a lot of the time, the desire for vengeance and the right to it are both lain at the feet of men instead of given into the hands of the survivor.

    It all kind of comes down to that sense of bewilderment the defendants exude, that sort of “I don’t get why you’re all so mad.” If they don’t understand precisely why what they did is repugnant, they can never take responsibility for it and would logically feel like their lives are being unfairly ruined.

    March 18, 2013 | 3:46 pm

Bill Parker

Great post.

Is Tomb Raider considered pro-geekgirl now? I admit my knowledge ends at or before the Angelina Jolie movies, but the whole appeal of Lara Croft seemed to be the parts of her anatomy that were frankly too large to permit her to realistically do any of the things she was doing. 🙂 Which is I think how women in games tend to be portrayed: pairs of boobs that only incidentally have other parts attached to them, and those parts sometimes (very) minimally move the story along. The best ones (and I saw that this came up in your post about the Gears of War idiot) seem to be the ones that let you choose for yourself, like Skyrim (though even that comes with user-created mods that let you put your character in thong armor and such). I bet if they did make a great game with a reasonably proportioned, fully clothed, awesome Buffy-type female lead (and maybe Tomb Raider has become that, I don’t know), it’d do very well. But there would be a certain portion of geekdom that never quite warmed to it for reasons they couldn’t quite name…and that’s basically what the Trio represents.

March 19, 2013 | 9:24 am

    Emmie Mears

    Physically, they made a huge effort this go-round to make her more normal looking. Smaller breasts, more natural proportions, and they put her in long trousers and a less revealing shirt. On the negative side (and this is just hearsay; I haven’t confirmed it), I heard they added a sexual assault to her backstory, which is just more of the same old trope people seem to think is new each time they come up with it. “Oh, you know what would explain this woman kicking so much ass? If she got raped once upon a time!” No.

    But anyway. Like I said, I don’t know if the latter is true, but I’m very glad they decided to make her look more like a normal person instead of a caricature. And the game is doing very well to extremely good reviews.

    March 19, 2013 | 9:36 am

      Daniel Swensen

      By all accounts I’ve heard, the controversial scene in question is not that bad. (By which I mean some very feminist friends who objected to the content up front decided to check it out and have reported that it’s more a physical threat than a sexual one. Disclaimer, I have not played it myself.)

      March 19, 2013 | 11:08 am

      Bill Parker

      I thought and hoped that might be the case. Thanks.

      March 19, 2013 | 11:08 am

Link Roundup | Feminist Fiction

[…] Buffy’s Trio: Do These Goofy Guys Spotlight Misogyny in Geek Culture? […]

March 22, 2013 | 8:01 am

Foxessa

For me the nerd/geek trio were the most awful of the Big Bads, and truly the most creepy. Because they are real. Worst of all, they are as boring and impossible to be around as are their real life counterparts. I hate them.

And yes, I did think of them in connection with Steubenville immediately I read the breaking story, back whenever it was — December? And until the verdict was announced last Sunday, I refused to read any more, as this is on the list of things I need to know about but don’t need to follow, and by not reading all the idiocies that get published and posted, I don’t go roaring insane and also clinically depressed; i.e. I can keep functioning, i.e. fighting.

March 24, 2013 | 4:27 pm

    Emmie Mears

    Yeah, I thought they were awful as well. They ended up killing a main character. I mean…as far as Buffy villains go, no other ones really succeeded in that.

    March 24, 2013 | 10:42 pm

Comments are closed.

  • Love this? Buy Emmie a Coffee. Mmm, coffee.

  • Newsletter of Newsiness Gets You A Free Ebook

    Want to be kept in the loop?

    * indicates required
    Email Format
  • Support My World-Making!

    Love my work or just want to support me directly? Come to my Patreon! You'll get all sorts of goodies in return!

  • SHRIKE: THE MASKED SONGBIRD (New Release!)

    Available in ebook. Trade paperback coming soon!

  • STORM IN A TEACUP (Book One of the Ayala Storme Series)

    Available in trade paperback and ebook.

  • Follow me on Twitter!

  • Show Your Like

  • Emmie on Goodreads

    What I'll Be Reading in 2014

    The Tombs of Atuan
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list
    Mistborn: The Final Empire
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list
    The Blade Itself
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list
    Elantris
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list
    Girl With a Pearl Earring
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list
    Magic Bites
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list
    Gone Girl
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list
    Claim Me
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list
    Shaman's Crossing
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: currently-reading and 2014-reading-list
    The Selkie Spell
    0 of 5 stars
    tagged: to-read and 2014-reading-list

    goodreads.com
  • Emmie on Pinterest

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers